Skip to Content

Foolish $40.05 High Mileage Instacart Order ($11.30 Tip)

Let’s break down this $40.05 high mileage Instacart order into average numbers so we can look at the real data behind this terrible offer. For all my breakdowns, these are absolutely the best-case scenarios. We are assuming you are already sitting in the store parking lot, the store isn’t crowded, and no items are out of stock, you hit every green light and cruise at an average highway speed of 60 MPH, and the drop-off goes perfectly smoothly.

The Real-World Labor & Transit Math

First, let’s look at the total time required to complete this order. The customer ordered 34 items, which totals up to 37 units. Even if you are a speed demon shopper, averaging a clean 1 item per minute, that means you are spending 34 minutes walking or running the aisles, grabbing the grocery items, handling the extra units, and checking out.

Next, we look at the distance of this $40.05 high mileage Instacart order. The delivery itself is a staggering 57 miles from the store, making it a massive 114-mile round trip back to your starting point. Cruising along at a steady speed, you will spend roughly 114 minutes total sitting behind the wheel to drop the groceries off and head right back to the store parking lot. When you add your 34 minutes of shopping time to your 114 minutes of travel time, it takes a total of 148 minutes of active labor to complete this entire order from start to finish.

Crunching the Net Profit of This $40.05 High Mileage Instacart Order

Now let’s subtract the real expense of operating your vehicle to find out what actually goes into your pocket. If you are driving a highly fuel-efficient vehicle that averages an incredible 50 MPG, you are going to burn through a little over two gallons of fuel. With gas priced at $4.00 per gallon, you are looking at exactly $9.12 in fuel costs to cover that long 114-mile loop. On top of that, we have to factor in standard vehicle maintenance at 4 cents per mile, adding another $4.56 of wear and tear to the trip.

When you combine that $9.12 gas cost with the $4.56 maintenance expense, your total vehicle overhead is $13.68. When we take the $40.05 gross payout from Instacart and subtract our $13.68 total vehicle expense, your actual net profit drops to $26.37.

The Pathetic Hourly Rate & Minimum Wage Reality

To find out what your time is truly worth on this offer, we divide that remaining $26.37 net profit by the 148 minutes of total labor it took to do the work. The math reveals you are grinding for a mere 17.8 cents per minute. When we scale that out by multiplying those cents across a full 60 minutes, this grueling highway marathon leaves you earning a real-world rate of just $10.69 per hour.

While a forty-dollar payout looks like a solid chunk of cash on a single screenshot, it is an absolute illusion when you look at the physical toll and distance involved. A regular employee gets a guaranteed hourly check without having to shell out massive chunks of cash for fuel or destroy their own vehicle’s lifespan. When an app expects you to take your car out into the middle of nowhere and log a brutal 114 miles of driving for a real-world wage that barely scrapes past a basic baseline, it’s an insult. This $40.05 high mileage Instacart order is a logistical trap, and it is officially DECLINED.

Order Rating

5 stars black outline 2 filled yellow on a white background.

An Unprofitable Bad Batch Covered in Deficient Pay


Explore Other Declined High Mileage Instacart Orders